Choosing Between a Memoir vs. Niche Blog

by Mandi on May 3, 2012

choosing memoir or niche blogging

source: D. Sharon Pruitt

There are some great posts in the archives of Life Your Way that don’t get much attention anymore. This week, I’ll be sharing some of my favorites. Whether you’ve been around since the beginning or are a new reader, I think you’ll enjoy them!

Many bloggers over the years have started blogging with the same purpose: to simply share pictures and stories of our children and family for friends and family members. This type of blogging is often referred to as mommy blogging, and it’s really an incredible opportunity for us to show off our families while also forging new online friendships, honing our writing skills and pushing ourselves to become better photographers.

At some point, many bloggers discover the power of their written words and decide to become more focused in their purpose and vision for their blog. Many of us also make this move for the opportunity to earn money from our blogs because memoir blogging is great for building a community, but only a select few earn a decent income from their mommy blogs.

When we’re talking about memoir versus niche blogging, neither one is better or worse than the other. Both have benefits and drawbacks, some of which we’ll look at here:

Memoir Blogging

  • Develop friendships, become part of the mommy blogging community
  • Show off your kids in pictures and words
  • Share whatever is on your mind without worrying about whether it “fits”
  • Free product & trip opportunities as you grow
  • Often a springboard into other personal & business opportunities
  • More competition for subscribers & visitors

Niche Blogging

  • Easier to monetize
  • Experience fast growth if you’re in a new or developing niche
  • Springboard for other business opportunities
  • Harder to share what’s on your mind if it’s unrelated to your niche
  • More pressure to post regularly and be “professional”
  • Involves a different kind of networking to connect with other bloggers in the niche

Moving from Memoir to Niche Blogging

Let me start by saying that if you’re happy with your memoir blog, there is no reason you need to change from a memoirist and begin blogging in a niche!

However, if you currently consider yourself a mommy blogger but would like to move to a niche blog, here are some thoughts to get you started.

Consider starting a new blog. In many cases, it will be easier for you to start a new niche blog rather than transform your current blog into something you didn’t intend it to be in the first place. Chances are that the readers of your personal blog come because they like to see pictures and hear stories about your family, and most bloggers find that they still want a place for their personal thoughts once they create a niche blog.

Narrow your focus. Successful niche blogs often have a very tight focus. In fact, that’s the main reason I expanded Organizing Your Way to the Life Your Way network. I wanted to be able to cover a wider variety of topics that are important to today’s families, and I didn’t want to keep doing that under the Organizing Your Way umbrella.

Think about what topics you’re passionate about and define your unique perspective. Perhaps you want to blog about quick & easy ways to be more green or things you can create from common household items or homeschooling a child with autism. Having a unique voice or perspective is an important part of being succesful in a niche.

Act like a professional. Once you begin a niche blog, act like a successful blogger. Keep your sidebar uncluttered. Spend more time proofreading posts than writing them. Be careful to properly credit anyone you quote or photographers whose Creative Commons photos you use. Post regularly so your readers know what to expect. Carefully choose opportunities that fit your vision.

Remember that it takes time. Although there are arguably more monetization opportunities with a niche blog, it will still take time to earn an income from your blog. Focusing on the money rather than your content is the quickest way to kill your blog before it gets off the ground. Instead, focus on the information you’re providing and connecting with readers for at least the first six months. At that point, if you’re established in the niche, you can begin experimenting with different things, although you always want to keep your content and readership first!

Do you consider yourself a niche blogger or a memoirist?

Mandi Ehman is the founder and publisher behind Life Your Way and the co-author of All in Good Time, as well as a wife and the homeschooling mom to four beautiful girls. She lives with her family on a little slice of heaven in wild, wonderful West Virginia and loves coffee, chocolate, easy meals, beautiful things and minimalist spaces.

  • http://hoperoadblog.com Anna

    I’m definitely a memoirist blogger (I love the “memoir blog” description), but am considering beginning a niche blog to grow into a small business someday, and because I absolutely love to write. I’m just pondering the right combination of my passion + others’ interest to decide on my niche.

  • http://homemakinghabits.blogspot.com Tacy

    I was a memoir blogger but was inspired mainly by the simple mom website to start homemaking habits. i would love to get feedback on how to make my niche blog more narrow, though. I don’t know what topics i would be willing to sacrifice in order to make it more narrow. Thanks for a great post! And I think the word “niche” is one of my favorite words. ever. :D

  • BerniceWood

    I started out briefly as a memoir blogger, but it quickly changed over to niche. I am keeping a personal blog, but will be launching a new niche blog in November!
    Bernice
    http://bernicewood.wordpress.com/2010/10/11/a-season-of-change-for-me-and-for-my-blog/

  • http://www.mommymisadventures.com/ Michelle M

    I am a memoirist. I began blogging back in 2000 (before “blog” was really a word) and have always maintained a personal blog. I tried niche blogging when I started my “mommy blog” in 2008 and was so put out by the impersonal nature of it. I am considering niche blogging again for my non-Mommy related business.

  • http://been-couraged.blogspot.com Karen

    I just found your blog today, and this post is sooo timely. I’ve been a memoir blogger off & on for a few years. Started and stopped a couple of times. But I am in the process now of starting my first niche blog on being both crunchy and a minimalist. I hope to be up and running by next week.

    Thanks for the pointers.

    • http://lifeyourway.net Mandi @ Life…Your Way

      Be sure to come back and share the link once you launch, Karen!

  • http://www.manylittleblessings.com Angie @ Many Little Blessings

    I have one memoir blog and two niche blogs. Both of my niche blogs are group blogs with other writers (though I edit/manage/write). I have to admit though, my favorite blog and the one I most consider “my” blog is my memoir one. I suspect because there is the most of me in it.

    • http://lifeyourway.net Mandi @ Life…Your Way

      I think for a lot of people that’s very true. I don’t really like to write memoir-y type stuff, but people who are passionate about writing and do it well definitely seem to have that pull inside of them to write that way!

  • Sarah Hoesly

    I just happened upon this particular blog, and it is timely for me as well! I have been an off-and-on memoir blogger for a few years, but frankly, it’s not all that thrilling to me to write about the daily activities of my family. So recently I started a “niche” blog, and I really love it. I’m completely and utterly clueless about what I’m doing though. I assume I’ll learn as I go along! Great post. If you want to see my new niche blog, here’s the url: http://www.ahundredfifty.com

    • http://lifeyourway.net Mandi @ Life…Your Way

      I love the premise behind your blog, Sarah — I just subscribed, and I can’t wait to see what you do!

  • capabilitymom

    Great post – very helpful. I initially started to blog for fun and to make myself write and soon found that I love everything that goes along with it. I have focused my blog and think social media is so interesting. I am also getting writing opportunities which has been fantastic.

  • http://www.thoughts-of-home.blogspot.com Carole

    I’m also a memoirist blogger – and have used the platform as a soapbox of sorts on things related to mothering, homeschooling, and a few crunchy topics as well. Lately I’ve been wondering how to narrow my focus and perhaps earn some money blogging. Your post helps as I consider the pros and cons. Thanks!

  • Johnmg3

    Awesome!!! I consider myself very tech savvy and even more so when it comes to my iPad. I knew how to close a program, but had never swiped to the right. Thank you so much for showing me this. You don’t know how much I’ve missed the screen orientation lock. Thanks!!

    • http://yourway.net Mandi @ Life Your Way

      You’re welcome!

  • la_lovenest

    i find this post to be very helpful. i recently decided to monetize my blog and make a career out of niche blogging. i feel that i have unique and meaningful ideas within each post. however, getting people to subscribe and follow and comment has been difficult. is there anyway you could make time to look at my blog and send me pointers on what could be helpful to draw in and maintain viewers? i’ve done countless hours of research on how to do it myself, but it would be such a relief to have someone offer up an opinion.

    thank you in advance for your time.

    sincerely,

    guerrillalovenest.blogspot.com

    • http://lifeyourway.net Mandi @ Life…Your Way

      I think that because your blog is really a very tight niche, it’s going to
      take some time to grow. My guess is that you’ll find lots of readers on
      Twitter and Facebook, and so that’s where you should focus your networking
      and promotional efforts. But I’m also guessing that it will spread quickly
      by word of mouth as you gain loyal readers!

  • http://fimby.tougas.net Renee @ FIMBY

    I’m catching this post the second time around. Love these descriptions Mandi.

    I straddle both in one blog and I love the freedom and flexibility in that. But I treat my blog quite professionally. In terms of writing commitment, how it looks (can’t stand cluttered messes), and the effort I put into writing. I look to Soule Mama as a model in the making money with a memorist/mommy blog”genre”

  • http://thedeliberatemom.blogspot.com/ Jennifer | The Deliberate Mom

    Wonderful tips! I don’t know how I would classify my blog. I guess it’s a memoir blog… but I’ve developed a variety of helpful articles within it too.

    I can’t see myself doing niche blogging. I like having complete freedom to write whatever I want whenever I feel like it.

  • mitstacia

    I love what you have done to expand your brand. I also want to get clear since I have a wide range of interests. 

Previous post:

Next post: